CO129-390 - Acting Governor Claud Severn - 1912 [5-6] — Page 397

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All

186

no span89 .Ji of jusɛɛn of beoubni ad Alwoo I darè coitqweas JI .hmotni flor me I Jud Jibs Hitz mog Jasel to Joulule niriş pataisor to podido wp sue one end to wely ni eno ed ton blvos prove di od otoveb or emit embe bail Iwoo eradhem or ti novO

tae, a Tolou ni yab

VIL'ì roodma wilt sewowth of grillke as I oud nahie dred yd of bantys memoidney Insbroqebui que deir phict Jaa. Calw po nekad pied nolstoob a od plymoute vier joejdo I

berteter oven I doine w unimo: xind bon enciszerqze edit bre and amulodiei noidatJîni sud Jund yviraalu opt? Vino voda

Teliab ya. 07 22 6d/tuo omni ed dem Itowel oviduɔexä

JOONEL I T (.88)

2

yonaliaszä »ili

piana-kinkubá muit10 erit

10 PY.

Sir,

Revision Room,

C.

385

PAGE 22 JUL 12

Law Courts,

6th. June, 1912.

I beg to acknowledge the receipt of your letter in which you inform me of the decision of the Executive Council on the subject of the Revised Edition. The Government has no right in law to withhold payment till they have scrutinized the work; they have a right to ask that the volumes should be accurate, and I have offered from the first to reprint any pages which any reasonable person as arbitrator considers sufficiently inaccurate to require it. I have not only offered this, but had given the necessary orders before your first letter reached me, and in order that there should be no mistake and, if possible, to avoid most unpleasant litigation, I hereby renew that offer.

So far as the question of copyright is concerned the law is too clear for argument, and the Government has practically admitted it. When the Government sought to obtain reprints of some of the Ordinances without consulting me I drew their attention to the fakt which they had overlooked that the copyright was mine, and the claim was never denied, nor could it be. The Ordinance itself expressly recognises my right to re- -print. I do not propose in view of the hostile attitude which you have without any reason adopted, to withdraw that claim or the MI claim for extra remuneration, though I have always been willing to submit the question to an impartial arbitrator. I have been com- -pelled to put it into a legal form because of the unreasonable- -ness of the Government attitude. You have overlooked the fact that the Executive Council stands pledged to deal with the matter "fairly*, and also that they have undertaken to pay the proper charges which have been incurred in consequence of the Government

amendments.

I am unwilling to sue the Government unless

I

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.